Re: Outdoor Swimming
Posted by: Anonymous User (---.in-addr.btopenworld.com)
Date: August 07, 2003 03:03PM
Beating, no. But there has to be a situation in which children know that they will be dealt with in some way if they knowingly do wrong, and why that is. Also, there ought to be praise when they do things that are right. A neighbour came round looking for her daughter (7?) who had been playing on Sarah's doorstep with a girl of 10. They had disappeared. I helped in the search. The ten year olds' mother was not there, having locked up the house and left the three children to fend for themselves. I suspect this is a regular occurence. We found the two of them, and the ten year old then put on airs that she had not done anything wrong. Next day she came round to take Sarah to task for having thought badly of her. And Sarah has been very good to her and her siblings. Next it was stones through the letterbox and in keyhole (cunning, but pointless).
My nephew once ran off against his parents wishes to see a friend ten miles away, pinching my bike into the process. He came back and hid, Eventually he got a complete screaming at, which taught him nothing. When I next saw him, I asked him quietly whether he thought that no one would mind what he had done, and whether it was really worth all that rather than asking people. Having taken it through step by step, I asked him how he felt about my approach. He said 'at least you know how to tell someone off'. He had no problem with being taught - unfocused yelling after leaving him to his own devices for long periods would have got nowhere. The impression I have is that where there are problems it may commonly be because :
mostly discipline consists of nothing, until it's too late, or yelling without explanation; and that getting things is achieved by harrassment and threats, rather than reward for good behaviour. Because it's easier to do it that way.
Oh dear, I hope I haven't got anyone's back up.