New users: Please register in the usual way and then send an email to jasper(at)jasperfforde.com with your username, and write something 'Ffordesque' so we know you are a real reader, and not some idiot trying to flood the forum with dodgy Nike and Gucci gear. Thank you - Jasper
Rick Deckard - far more rounded and angst-ridden in the book - would definitely fit.
(While I like the second version of "Blasde-Runner", I actually also quite like the original voice-over version, which everyone else seems to hate. I haven't yet managed to see the 3rd so-called final edit, but will probably try to watch all three back to back.)
SkidMarks Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Rick Deckard - far more rounded and angst-ridden
> in the book - would definitely fit.
>
> (While I like the second version of
> "Blasde-Runner", I actually also quite like the
> original voice-over version, which everyone else
> seems to hate. I haven't yet managed to see the
> 3rd so-called final edit, but will probably try to
> watch all three back to back.)
So do I, wasn't aware that there was a 3rd version out.
As too who I'd vote in ....... Lady Sharrow from Iain M Banks Against a Dark Background, quite rounded and grown up up by the end.
I think perhaps I have seen all versions except the first with the voice over? didn't know about that one. I don't like voice overs- I'd choose subtitles evertyime. Even if they are humourous like on Jackie Chan movies ^_^
__________________________________
'We're all mad here. I'm mad, you're mad." [said the Cat.]
"How do you know I'm mad?" said Alice.
"You must be," said the Cat, "Or you wouldn't have come here."
- Lewis Carroll, Alice's Adventures In Wonderland
No need for Deckard. Jasper has already got Gully Foyle to police science fiction. Which is a great choice. I love Alfred Bester's "Stars My Destination," (or "Tiger, Tiger" in the UK).
Jaws from James Bond? Wasn't he only in the movies? It's been so long since I read Ian Fleming. I don't recall Jaws being in there. Oddjob yes... Dr. No .... definitely. Jasper does need a Jurisfiction agent for adventure fiction.
Who should police mystery/detective? Miss Marple?
And I like your idea of Frankenstein for horror fic. Some quirky Anne Rice character would be good too. Lasher?
BibwitHart Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I think perhaps I have seen all versions except
> the first with the voice over? didn't know about
> that one. I don't like voice overs- I'd choose
> subtitles evertyime. Even if they are humourous
> like on Jackie Chan movies ^_^
Ah you've gotthe wrong end of the stick there. The voice over was done by Harrison Ford(no relation) as the studio thought the film was a bit bleak without it and needed some kind of cheeryness in it.
Harry Bosch! Good pick. He could handle the hardboiled detective fiction. Now what about the British drawing room murder mystery stuff....Adam Dalgliesh?
If you are going into Diana Wynne Jones, I'd reccommend Derk from The dark lord of Derkolm or perhaps Howl- now he'd be good! (Howl's moving castle, the novel not the animation!!!!) He was meant to be a complete and total Coward!!
She might agree, she is friends with Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett- she has hinted at some of Terry's Characters before. A t-shirt in Deep Secret that says Oook!
John Rebus would make a great Jurisfiction agent for Scottish detective literature and Louie Welch for the Welsh sub genre. And how about Saruman for mystery/horror as all we ever see is his eye!